“Real Photography” If You Use This Phrase, You May Be A Jerk

Bald Eagle by Scott Bourne

“Real Photography” If You Use This Phrase, You May Be A Jerk

EDITORIAL

Okay – sorry, but I need to vent. I haven’t written much in this style lately, and I promise to move on to more positive things in my next post, but I am sick and tired of photographers using click bait by writing stories about what does and does not constitute “real photography.”

To be clear – NOBODY BUT YOU gets to decide what’s “real photography.” Anyone else who tries to tell you is a jerk – straight up.

In an attempt to gin up audience, several photography sites have lately taken to telling the rest of us what is and is not permissible in the world of photography. To them – to each and every one of them – I say – mind your own business. I’m going to decide what constitutes photography for me. Nobody else gets to do that.

Some of these conversations have been going on for centuries – in one form or another. Is this REAL art? Is this REAL photography? The debate will continue for centuries. As photographers/artists, it should not concern us or in any way impact what we do. If it’s a photograph to you – then by God it’s a photograph.

As for the people spreading this garbage…Just who do these self-appointed photography police think they are? I understand why they write click bait, but this is a low blow.

I generally consider this sort of behavior to be trolling. And I always ignore trolls. But in this case, I am making mention of the situation because I fear it will potentially do harm to those who are just starting out in photography and looking to establish themselves as artists. You new folks need to know that there are no rules in photography. Everything is fair game. Unless…

There are exceptions – primarily for photo journalists. The journalist with a camera has ethical obligations to stick to the truth as much as possible. Editing photos to turn them into something different than they were at the moment of capture is unacceptable for these photographers. Additionally, I personally don’t believe that anyone should use their camera to mislead people. Beyond that, and the exception for photojournalists, everything is fair game as far as I am concerned. Everything and anything.

For me – and I am just speaking for myself – if the image I share starts in a camera, then it’s a photograph. It is a PHOTOGRAPH. Plain and simple. A photograph. People are of course free to disagree with me – and I am of course free to ignore them.

If someone else is telling you what is and is not a photograph, my recommendation is to move on. Life is too short to let trolls ruin your art.

Okay – safety glasses off. We now return you to your normal programming. I apologize if I offended anyone by being so blunt. But it needed to be said.


Picture Methods has partnered with Hunt’s Photo & Video to bring you the best gear at a competitive price and backed by personal service. Call Alan Samiljan at 781-462-2383 if you need photo/video gear. If you prefer, you can also email Alan at: alansamhunts@gmail.com or just visit the Hunt’s Photo & Video Website deals page.

 

6 Responses

  1. I mostly agree with you Scott, but I have my own caveat. Photo competitions need to have some boundaries to ensure a level playing field and to provide the photographer the guidance needed to enter appropriate images.

    But for the sake of art, anything goes. And in fact it has often been the “experimenters” who have pushed photography to new levels.

    Thanks for the rant!

    1. Thanks David – I guess it would depend on the competition but I don’t enter many these days so I don’t have a strong opinion about that. Where I bog down is people who decide what constitutes photography and what does not get caught up in the process and NOT the picture and for me, that is completely backwards. I really don’t much care how someone gets the picture – I care about the picture 🙂

  2. My photography and image making career really started to take off when I realised that you don’t have to follow the rules others want to place on you. I could use Photoshop, combine exposures, composite, re-colour and so on. I don’t care if it’s judged to be photography or not anymore. It was enormously freeing to have this revelation.

  3. Never understood why people feel the need to level criticisms at the work of others. I actually really like and appreciate your affirmations in the podcast directed at positivity. A definite step in the right direction!

Leave a Reply to Scott BourneCancel reply

Category

Archives

Archives
Related

Related Post

My Favorite Canon R5 Accessories

I am super impressed with the trio. But when you add any new camera...

Update On Why I’m No Longer A Full-time Olympus Shooter

Lots of you have been reaching out to ask me about my experimentation with...

Private* Bird Photography/Video Workshops In Arizona

Come join me for a rare, private bird photography or video workshop in southern...

Discover more from PictureMethods

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading